My favorite science, and the story of the neutrino
64What is my favorite science, you ask? And, why?
“We are made of star stuff. For the most part, atoms heavier than hydrogen were created in the interiors of stars and then expelled into space to be incorporated into later stars.” ~Carl Sagan
I wasn’t one of the lucky kids who had cable TV. No mere rabbit ears for us, though. We were rockin’ a 12 foot wide roof mounted TV antenna. We dialed in those four precious channels with the precision of Apollo flight controllers.
Depending on the weather, of course. Even NASA would have struggled to tune in ABC during a clear cloudless night in northern Michigan.
Unless there was a storm system moving in, the easiest channel to tune was PBS. Public Broadcasting Service.
Commercial free, documentary filled, occasionally boring, and home of the most influential television series of my life: Cosmos.
A soothing, gentle piano is the last thing we expect to hear at the start of an epic production. Back in 1980 though, it was a cue. Grab your snack, run to the living room, sit yourself down and don’t make a sound for the next hour.
“...to find the truth, we need imagination and skepticism both.”
Sagan’s Ship of the Imagination was the ultimate in hokey. Still, to an 8-year-old in the Cronkite Era, a simple desk and chair facing a “windshield” was pretty damn neat. Sure, there was no CGI. HD? Hell, no!
But, a wide open imagination... check.
Here is a story is so beautiful that it chokes up the most steadfast nerd.
In 1930, an Austrian physicist named Wolfgang Pauli had a problem.
He was measuring neutrons, and he found that parts of them were... disappearing.
Fundamental particles cannot disappear. Things don’t just go poof. It’s The Law.
Spotted on an MIT message board, December, 2009:
“Seriously. I'm trying to go to bed, but these f$#@ng solar neutrinos are keeping me up.
It's already 1:00 AM. Should I call the cops?”
Pauli was studying a nuclear reaction known as Beta Decay. When a neutron decays, it emits an electron and then becomes a proton. Pauli measured the three components of the initial neutrons:
- Mass
- Energy
- Momentum
When he measured the post-decay electrons and protons, he found that the total mass was unchanged. Oddly though, the second measurement showed less energy and less momentum.
1 + 1 + 1 was not equaling 3.
There were only two possible explanations:
- Spooky Voodoo
- Invisible, undetectable, weightless particles with no electrical charge whatsoever that travel at the speed of light and do not interact with matter must be carrying away the missing energy and momentum.
Number 2 kinda sounds like a “science-y” way of saying spooky voodoo, don’t ya think? Lots of scientists thought so too. At first.
Pauli proposed the existence of particles so small that they had no mass, yet contained large amounts of energy and momentum. Imagine the Invisible Man running laps around the gym. At light speed. In zero gravity.
The mystery particles were named neutrinos. The Little Neutral Ones.
Aww, they’re cute.
ACTUAL PHOTOGRAPH OF A NEUTRINO
In 1987, water-based detectors below Earth’s surface actually detected
neutrinos that were emitted from a supernova that happened the in
Tarantula Nebula. Before this incident, the only neutrinos we had
detected came either from our own planet or our sun.
Supernova neutrinos! But, that's a whole ‘nother story...
Throughout the 30’s and 40’s, physicists noodled with the seemingly impossible idea. Science-y voodoo is worth exploring when the only alternative is flat out spooky.
After 25 years of theory and experiment, two American physicists at last detected real, live, honest to goodness neutrinos that were produced by nuclear reactions at the Savannah River Reactor in South Carolina. Nobel Prizes for all.
We need imagination and skepticism both.
I'm so choked up...
Neutrinos, the impossible particles, are actually so common in our universe that in the blink of your eye, one trillion of them ripped right through your body.
Oh, there they went again. Again. Stop blinking.
If you had a
chunk of lead that was 100 light years long, that chunk of lead would
absorb only 1 out of every 3 neutrinos that pass through its entire length.
We figured out how to detect them just the same.
(Cue the choked up nerd.)
Astronomy is the oldest science.
Add to that the funky world of physics, and there you have it: my favorite science.
Why? Because I was one of the lucky kids who didn’t have cable TV.
More astronomy!
- Meet the planets: our solar system's roster
Read quick facts about each planet in the solar system. See NASA images from Hubble, Voyagers 1 and 2, Cassini, and more. - 2 years ago
- SN1987A: The story of a supernova
What is SN1987A? A supernova is the largest explosion in the known universe. The Hubble Space telescope has taken hundreds of pictures of this supernova. - 2 years ago
- My favorite science, and the story of the neutrino
Carl Sagan's Cosmos on PBS inspired a lifetime of interest in science. Neutrinos were proposed in theory in 1933, and proven to exist in 1956. Nerds are still rejoicing. - 2 years ago
![]() | Amazon Price: $56.63 List Price: $99.98 |
![]() | Amazon Price: $10.92 List Price: $19.99 |
![]() | Amazon Price: $27.06 List Price: $59.98 |
![]() | Amazon Price: $8.24 List Price: $17.00 |
CommentsLoading...
J-Kep:
Quantum physics absolutely confused Einstein.
Information that was being discovered refuted so much of macro physics.
There is no doubt, since space constitutes the majority of all mass, that we humans are just beginning to understand existence.
Quantum physics and genetic engineering are the harbinger of incredible things to come...if we don't destroy our species prematurely.
I saw every episode of Carl Sagans "Cosmos."
Nice "hub!"..:-)
A fantastic hub! The subject is great and most interesting to me, but fair dinkum, you are one hell of a good writer.
You use the language the way many, myself included wish we could. To express your point with accuracy and humour. I loved it!
I also enjoyed seeing a photo of a neutrino for the first time ever!
Wonderful hub! I too was young in the Cronkite era. Perhaps...it was then that nerds began to multiply.
I really enjoyed reading this! Thanks! :)
hee hee...love dat actual photgraph of a neutrino :D
We didn't have a telly at all until I left home so missed the cosmos series. But you have explained it all so clearly it really doesn't matter. Next lesson please




















Denno66 2 years ago
This was an awesome Hub! I love AstroPhysics, myself. Nerdy? Eh, who cares? I find it interesting. Carl Sagan was and still is my all-time favorite Astro-Geek. Great job!